I have tried those other products. Some of those fancy brand towelettes would rip the surface of my skin off and leave my eyelids raw. I have converted to CeraVe Daily Moisturizing Lotion. Not only does it effectively remove eye make up, it is good for my skin. It is also great for moisturizing neck skin for a more youthful appearance. I suffer no alcohol sting when it comes in contact with my eye surface, also cruelty free.